My Week as a Scold
Posted: March 25, 2013 Filed under: Uncategorized | Tags: landmines, minefield 3 CommentsSometimes writing this blog I feel like a bit of a scold: constantly reminding the Ether of the threat of landmines and their impact upon the lives of individuals. I also get deeply offended when I see people casually toss of the words “minefield” or “landmine” for dramatic effect. Two weeks ago I saw a story from Forbes entitled, “Traversing Personal Brand Management While Avoiding Company Brand Landmines” and thought company brand landmines must surely be the least dangerous form of landmines and by using the word “landmines” in this context the author really cheapened the lives of people killed or injured by real landmines. But I held my tongue. Over the following weekend, I resolved not to. I decided that every story I came across during the week of March 17 to 22 that used the words “minefield” or “landmine(s)” would get the following response:
Dear …
Every day, a dozen people are killed or injured by landmines around the world. Your casual use of the word “minefield / landmine(s)” is disrespectful of their fate. If you want to learn more about the impact of real landmines, please visit www.the-monitor.org or www.LandminesinAfrica.org.
Sincerely,
Michael P. Moore
And after posting, I would track the responses and provide additional details to anyone who sought them and avoid internet firestorms and trolls. I commented or emailed the authors of the following articles, retrieved by Google news searches. Any responses I received are in italics:
Suu Kyi Walks Through a Minefield
Traversing Personal Brand Management While Avoiding Company Brand Landmines
Citizens is political minefield in Capitol debate
Navigating the Emotional Minefield When Giving Performance Feedback
Response:
Hi Michael,
No disrespect intended. I really only meant to use the term in the second sense listed here [from www.Merriam-Webster.com: Minefield, Definition 2: something resembling a minefield especially in having many dangers or requiring extreme caution].
I apologize for sounding cavalier. I only meant that supervisors are proceeding into “something resembling a minefield especially in having many dangers or requiring extreme caution.”
Guy
High-speed rail project beset by political mine fields
Call to let juries know criminal past ‘a justice minefield’
Cultivating Sources Can Be A Minefield For Women Reporters
Mumbai driving ‘like hopscotch in a minefield’
Flash support is increasingly a minefield
Land Mine Attachement: OPT13 (the mis-spelling is in the original; I was tempted, but did not mention it)
The minefield of social media metrics
Obama heads into Mideast minefield
Offensive material on social media proving legal minefield
Spiers on Sport: how the SNP have made policing fans a minefield
Congressman Talks Political Landmines To Manage Cuts
Coping With the Minefield: Confronting Investors
Background Checks and the EEOC: Navigating the Minefield
Response:
I sincerely apologize to amyone who found the title offensive in any way. That was not my intent.
Insurance Policy Conditions (a/k/a/ Land Mines): Part 21 – “Intent” and the Fraud Condition
Danger! Beware of Legal Landmines in Your Company’s Records
In the event, not much changed. Two authors (out of 21) will hopefully think twice before using terms like “landmine” and “minefield” in their writing, so I’ll call those wins, but the vast majority of comments went either unanswered or were not even posted by the moderator. I did register new accounts with BDLive, the Huffington Post, the Yorkshire Post, Sunshine Coast Daily and Forbes. I still feel like a scold, but I will embrace that role in the future.
Michael P. Moore
March 25, 2013
I think notifying writers of words that have become used in a generic manner is always a good idea, and the ones who respond to you are really to be commended for paying attention and taking time to give more thought to their word use.
Dear Michael,
Ordinary people, caught up in their own lives, often need reminders about the overall world’s “big screen.” Thank you for being a scold.
Warm wishes,
Laurel Anne Hill, Moderator of the Minds Clearing Land Mines WordPress Blog
Video gamers forum discusses whether landmines should be added to their game.
http://forums.station.sony.com/ps2/index.php?threads/who-thinks-they-should-add-landmines.111170/
Also, a forum was discussing whatever happened to Minesweeper, the game Microsoft used to install on every computer with Windows. One forum said Microsoft changed landmines to flowers after an anti-mine campaign in Italy complained. How many computers still have Minesweeper as a pre-installed game?